you're reading ...

Seed-saving is Political!

Sunflower Seeds

Who owns 'em?

If the thought of a multinational corporation actually owning a whole species makes you feel extremely uneasy, you’re not alone. And your uneasiness isn’t misplaced.

We’re talking about the commercial seed industry. It turns out this industry is doing a lot more than just collecting and distributing seeds: it’s working on owning them, too.

How is that possible, you might ask? Seeds are a naturally occurring, reproducing, living part of our planet. They’ve been around for thousands and thousands (and thousands) of years. They don’t belong to anyone. If anything, they belong to everyone.

While the commercial seed industry certainly can’t own, say, “the tomato,” it certainly can own its own particular breed of tomato, which it engineers and then patents. Once it does so, this tomato functions in the marketplace not as one more species on a planet full of special diversity, but as a product whose rights are strictly owned by its inventor.


(1) You can’t save the seeds of such a tomato. For one thing, it’s likely a hybrid, which means that when you plant the seeds it produces, you don’t know what kind of tomato is going to sprout from them. (The answer is, probably not a very good one.)

For another, it’s illegal. It’s copyright infringement. It’s like buying a book, then printing copies. As one article puts it:

“Farmers who buy Monsanto’s patented Roundup Ready seeds are required to sign an agreement promising not to save the seed
produced after each harvest for re-planting, or to sell the seed to other farmers. This means that farmers must buy new seed every

They’re allowed to do that because, under the WTO’s General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), modern seeds are considered intellectual property.

(2) Another thing. If you’re a farmer, and your neighbor’s growing one of these crops, if any of your neighbor’s crops go to seed, and if any of those seeds float over to your land (as seeds will do) and start to grow, you’re liable. Key words: infringement lawsuits.

It wouldn’t be such a problem if these commercial hybrids weren’t taking over the food industry. Meanwhile, heirlooms and open-pollinated varieties get lost under the onslaught. Michael Pollan writes:

“In the last few decades F-1 hybrids... have become the stock in trade of the commercial seed industry, and they are gradually
crowding traditional 'open pollinated' varieties... out of the marketplace... [with the result that] almost half of all the nonhybrid
vegetable varieties on the market just 10 years ago have been dropped from mail-order catalogues. This often results in extinction.
Farming Rice in Thailand

Thailand Village Farmers at Work

As modern species displace the ancient ones, we become more and more dependent upon modern corporations for our food. In the process, these corporations acquire a monopoly – not just on some bunch of goods or services, but on… food.

Actually, it wasn’t so long ago there were laws against that. Laws like, you can’t patent a living thing. Which is still true, to some extent. But with the Plant Patent Act of 1930, followed by the institution of Plant Variety Protection in 1970, it became possible to own a cultivar you created.

Problem? Read these excerpts from an article by the human rights organization 3D, and you decide.

“In rural areas all over the developing world, women like Yaowapa Promwong in Thailand have traditionally been seed savers and
plant breeders. Until a decade ago, knowledge of seed selection and conservation enabled villagers in Yaowapa’s community to grow
produce appropriate to their land. Heritage seeds have been passed down over generations, along with the family land. 

“Around 10 years ago, many farmers were invited to government workshops on how to industrialize their farms and raise productivity
for export. Several large agri-business companies attended these workshops and gave out gifts of seeds, fertilizers and pesticides,
which farmers adopted with enthusiasm. 

“Many farming families have now discontinued seed saving, turning instead to seeds from agri-businesses that supposedly know the
market demand. Yaowapa describes the resulting changes in her village as socially and environmentally devastating. Her story is not

“Behind the scenes, intellectual property rights (IPRs) on seeds are playing their part in her story. IPRs are accused of interfering with
traditional farming and cultural practices, disempowering women and making farmers more vulnerable to market fluctuations. IPRs on
seeds are said to contribute to loss of genetic and cultural diversity and to increased corporate concentration, which could result in
environmental degradation and undermine long-term sustainability of food supplies.
Tomato Start

It all starts here.

If the idea of a few corporations controlling the bulk of the world’s food makes you not only uneasy, but kind of repulsed… if you believe that no human being (or organization of human beings) should be able to own a common resource so basic as food… then you should consider saving seeds.

To opt out of the monopoly game, start by planting your garden with traditional, non-hybrid species. The kind that reproduce the natural way. The kind that, most importantly, aren’t owned by multinational corporations. Michael Pollan again:

“...the decision to plant one variety and not another is freighted with moral and environmental significance. A political fight is not
exactly what I came to vegetable gardening to pick, but I seem to have stumbled into one (ibid.).

When you’re in the farm and garden store browsing for seeds, look for Seed Savers Exchange, a non-profit seed distributor dedicated to helping people do just what we’re talking about. You can’t go wrong with anything you get from them.

Otherwise, keep your eyes peeled for the words “open-pollinated,” “heritage” and “heirloom.” These are the varieties you want to support. When you help them propagate, you help protect them from extinction.

Don’t underestimate the power you have to preserve and protect our food supply. When backyard gardeners do what people have been doing since agriculture began – collecting, saving and planting our own seeds – we’re participating in a very old, very valuable tradition. One which has always been done at the grass-roots.

Oh – and if you’re not sure how to save seeds, you might want to read our post on that: Seed-saving in 6 Simple Steps.

Happy reading, and happy planting!


About Healing Ponds Farm

Healing Ponds is 40 acres in Buxton, OR. Our farm store, Ludemans Farm & Garden Center, is in Beaverton. We do open-pollinated seeds, pastured eggs and meats, raw milk herd shares, chicks and a lot of other things.


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Type your email address below, and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 68 other followers

Pic of the Week

We sell beef. 100% pastured.

We sell beef. 100% pastured. Ask for details.

%d bloggers like this: